The Thrill of Encountering an Ideal Reader

“The Jane Austen Project” has been out in the world for two and a half years now, and I’ve given up thinking that anything else will ever happen involving it. (Though I suppose Andrew Davies could call at any moment wanting to follow up on the critical and popular acclaim of “Sanditon” by making “Project” into a mini-series, for instance, the chances seem small. )Two and a half years later, having published a novel feels quite a lot like not having published a novel. I am struggling to write a second and wondering what I think I am doing.

So it is gratifying when something happens to remind me that the book still exists out in the world. A few weeks ago I got an email from a woman inviting me to come and visit her book club. Although doing so involved a trip by commuter rail in the middle of the workweek, I accepted the invitation, if apprehensively, telling myself it would be “good to meet readers.” To put my thumb on the pulse of the reading public. But the warm welcome I got from the book club exceeded anything I could possibly have hoped for.  Its members’ questions made it clear they had read the novel closely and with great sympathy and penetration: that they were, in fact, the sort of ideal reader one always dreams of encountering in real life and seldom does.

One “ideal reader” experience per month is a lot! But yesterday, it got better, when Girl With Her Head in Book, a British book blogger I’ve long admired, published a review of “Project” that made it equally clear that she understood exactly what I had set out to do (and approved):

…A direct confrontation between our twenty-first social mores and those of Georgian Britain. Skating over the particulars of the time travel mechanism, The Jane Austen Project is less science fiction and more thought experiment.

To say I was honored and touched by this review would be a huge understatement. The praise was kind, but it was more than that. To be understood is what we all ever hope for in sending out into the world something we’ve created, and when it happens it is always an enormous thrill. Thank you, “Girl,” so much.


8 thoughts on “The Thrill of Encountering an Ideal Reader

  1. The Jane Austen Project is fabulous! I really meant to post a review of it but got a little sidetracked. I loaned my copy to somebody in my office at work and she adored it too. Wouldn’t it be marvellous to see it on our TV screens?


  2. I love your book, and I keep checking every now and then to see if you have written a new one. For your readers, your having published a novel is not at all like your not having published a novel — it is much better!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Awww how lovely! I love Girl With Her Head In A Book too, and I can only imagine how incredibly exciting it must have been to see your own book there. Good on you, doll! Keep connecting with those readers, and bringing joy to the world!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.